A Love of Reading….or Not
May 10, 2007
I have never really liked fiction. Ever.
I remember being in 2nd and 3rd grades, being shooed into the fiction section of our school library to pick out books. At one point my teacher even required that I take out at least one book because my preference was to simply sit down and wait for everyone else to be finished so we could go already. Never once did anyone suggest I try non-fiction. It was a small, quarantined section that no one ever wandered into unless you had to do a report. Kids like fiction.
Even in high school fiction titles abound. We read tons of fiction as a class. I hated it. We were required to read books from the teacher’s library – all fiction. It was torture for me. The teachers simply didn’t understand that it wasn’t a matter of being lazy. I enjoyed reading…. just not reading fiction. But that wasn’t the case with any other kids I knew so I guess I can’t blame the teachers for not believing me.
So now here I am. A homeschooling mom who desires to pass along a love of reading good literature to my kids….a love I don’t have. I’ll sometimes read fiction titles with the girls but more often when I read to them, it’s non-fiction because that’s what I enjoy. The girls seem much more ‘normal’ than I and choose to read fiction on a regular basis. While I’m pleased with that, I can’t shake the guilt that I’m not being a good enough example for them by reading fiction myself.
So what do you think? Is reading non-fiction a good enough ‘example’? Do I need to read more fiction to them, even if it’s not something I enjoy? How important do you think fiction literature is for a well balanced education and how is it best delivered?
May 10, 2007 at 2:36 pm
I think this kind of thing will be an issue for me also. This is something that concerns me as I start my homeschool journey. I hope that I will be able to teach material that I don’t find interesting. I think exposing them to both forms of literature and letting them make the choice of what they enjoy reading is really the only way to go. As far as feeling guilty about not liking something, you shouldn’t, you are just being who you are. Ultimately, like you, they are going to gravitate to the stuff they find interesting. I personally prefer non-fiction to fiction myself.
Take care,
Dawn A.
May 11, 2007 at 11:30 am
I’ve been thinking about the same things, thanks for bringing this up.
I wouldn’t worry about emphasizing non-fiction at all. Why do you want your kids to be excellent readers? So they can entertain themselves with the latest best-seller or so that they can find the information they need to function effectively in the world?
I want to pass a love of thinking and problem solving to my kids. If they have that, they’ll find that they have to read, and they love to read, to chase whatever interest they happen to have. And one day they might decide they like reading fiction.
Exposure to fiction literature is still important. If kids do like it, they will start reading, improve as readers, and have fun doing it. But don’t force it on them and don’t pretend you like it when you don’t.
May 11, 2007 at 9:08 pm
Thanks, Rolfe. That’s a good point.